Tuhoe’s Bloody Sunday

skink 3 (Custom)
Wright’s skink, web endemic to Seychelles, obesity on Aride Island

My story on ecological restoration in Seychelles has just been published on National Geographic’s website (with a compilation of video clips at the start), and will soon be available in the March 2016 print edition.
One of the islands I visited, but which didn’t end up being included in the story, was Aride, which has been a nature reserve for 50 years. Unlike some privately owned island reserves in Seychelles, which have luxury resorts on them, Aride is home only to nature and a handful of caretaker staff. I was there for less than 24 hours, but I felt a quiet enchantment on Aride that I experienced nowhere else. Here’s a short account of that visit. . . .

I have a knack, it seems, of finding the one seat on any small open boat that gets the greatest soaking from the sea. And so it proved on the eight-mile journey by inflatable from Praslin to Aride—one a well populated residential and resort island in the eastern Seychelles, the other a privately owned nature reserve with a caretaker staff of six. I arrived well drenched, but that was no hardship in the tropical heat of Seychelles. And especially not when stepping ashore on one of Seychelles’ best preserved enclaves of indigenous wildlife.

As with most Seychelles islands, Aride was heavily cleared for coconut plantations in the 1800s, and the copra era persisted until well into the 20th century. Despite the coming and going of vessels to carry coconuts away for processing, not to mention the movement of labourers on and off the island, Aride somehow escaped being invaded by rats. As a result, much of the island’s ground-dwelling reptile and invertebrate fauna remains intact, and now that the island is a reserve, seabird populations are rebounding. More than a million roseate terns, lesser noddies and tropical shearwaters breed on the rocky slopes of the island.

On a night walk with wildlife officer Juan Michel I heard the haunting calls of wedge-tailed shearwaters, and next morning I watched seabirds emerging from the forest canopy as if being breathed out like winged pollen. White terns, noddies, shearwaters, and, soaring above them all, crawling across the sky in slow motion, frigatebirds, pirates of the sky.

Aride may be a reserve for nature, but old human habits die hard. Every year, in seabird breeding season, island staff see lights on the hillsides where poachers are taking eggs and chicks—a throwback to earlier times when up to 200,000 sooty tern eggs might be taken each year. The harvest persisted for a century, until in 1967 the island’s owner put a stop to it and declared Aride a nature reserve. For the past few years, armed guards have been deployed, and arrests made, but the relevant laws have loopholes, convictions are rare and sentences light.

For many Seychellois, harvesting from nature is an entitlement, regardless of law or conservation status. Juan Michel told me that many Seychellois retain a blind faith that nature’s storehouses are inexhaustible. Their fundamental premise is “God will provide,” Michel said. “I say to them, ‘The blue kestrel is extinct. The moorhen is extinct. In 1990 there were 12 magpie robins left. These birds were all once abundant. What happened? Why didn’t God provide? Did they just vanish, or were humans to blame?’”

Michel grew up on Aldabra, Seychelles’ westernmost atoll and a World Heritage site of outstanding ecological value. His father was the administrator. He recalled turtle eggs being broken on his head to make his hair grow thick and long. In those days, not only was turtle meat a staple, it was common practice to drink green turtle blood for its supposed health benefits. It appalled Michel. Rather than eat turtle, he ate flour and water dough. “There are still Seychellois who kill dolphin and turtle,” he told me. “I don’t know the taste of those meats.”

To Seychellois who argue with him about the cultural tradition of eating turtle, calling it a “God-given right,” he retorts: “Just because everything on earth is God-given doesn’t mean you have to eat it.” He added wistfully to me, “Why is it we like the taste of the ones on the endangered list?”

Aride was bought by Christopher Cadbury, a member of Britain’s first family of chocolate, in 1973, and in 1979 it became a special reserve under Seychelles law, with a small marine protected area extending 200 metres offshore.

According to Michel, Cadbury gave strict instructions to his children that no fancy resort was ever to be built on the island. And that’s how it is today. Staff live in a collection of spartan huts just back from the beach. Further inland, in a forest clearing, is the old copra plantation manager’s house. When they came to the island, the Cadburys lived here—two rooms with no glass windows, just shutters; no air conditioning, just shady eaves. The weatherboards have aged to a dark-brown colour, the colour of chocolate.

When I went to look at the house, a magpie robin darted in and perched on the back of a chair on the verandah. It seemed an eloquent reminder of a benefactor’s timely purchase. A bird on the brink of extinction, now flourishing on an island set aside not for touristic benefit but ecological preservation.

Arid in name, but not in nature.


raid 2 new
Police approach Maungapohatu through the rugged Te Urewera forest. / Alexander Turnbull Library

On this day 100 years ago a notorious arrest took place.

It happened at Maungapohatu—Tuhoe’s sacred mountain and site of a messianic community established by prophet Rua Kenana.

On Sunday April 2, online
1916, sale
Police Commissioner John Cullen led a column of 57 sweating constables, armed with automatic pistols and carbines, up a steep path from the valley below. They had walked all the way from Ruatahuna, deep in the forest heartland of Te Urewera, to apprehend the prophet on charges of sedition and resisting arrest.

In a show of contempt, Cullen flouted protocol and rode his horse on to the marae and up to a newly built wharenui where Rua stood with two of his sons. Cullen demanded Rua’s immediate surrender.

From somewhere, a shot was fired—it has never been determined from which side—and a short but disastrous exchange of fire left Rua’s son Toko and his uncle, Te Maipi, dead, and several on both sides injured.

Further horror followed. Descendants speak of rape and torture. Several men were mock-buried in an open grave. Jewellery, money and greenstone taonga were pillaged as trophies.

The events of that day have seared Tuhoe’s memory, and continue to do so, despite Crown apologies and a landmark treaty settlement.

Catching the ‘Maori Kaiser’

Rua’s arrest was part of a vendetta born of wartime paranoia and intolerance. These were jingoistic times. The First World War was being fought in the mud and the trenches of Europe. Memories of Gallipoli were still fresh in people’s minds.

Despite the fact that Rua’s community had called itself Te Maungarongo, the people of lasting peace, Rua and his followers were suspected of treasonous intent. In the newspapers Rua was painted as a dangerous renegade and branded “the Maori Kaiser.” It was said he welcomed a German victory, and that he had built up a cache of weapons “obtained from Assyrian hawkers.” His influence had to be neutralised.

The pugnacious Cullen—nicknamed “Czar Cullen” by historian Mark Derby on account of his head-cracking style of policing—had been successful in breaking the Waihi miners’ strike in 1912. Now he was sent in to extract Rua from his “stronghold.” A report at the time suggested that “overwhelming force” might be required.

From houses on the hillside above the wharenui, the community would have watched with mounting dread as the police massed in front of the marae. Many of Rua’s followers had been children during the military invasions of Te Urewera during the 1860s. “They could recall the hunger and the pain, the smell of smoke from the burning kainga, the thud of muskets and the cries of the wounded,” wrote Derby in his book The Prophet and the Policeman. “They knew what it was like to be helpless as an invading army incinerated their homes and destroyed their crops.”

As the police approached, Rua and his sons stepped off the verandah and walked forward to welcome their guests. But being a “guest” was the furthest thing from Cullen’s mind, and he wasn’t about to wait to be invited on to the marae. “I was entitled to go armed to a man whom I knew to be a desperado,” he said later, justifying his belligerent approach.

Cullen expected armed resistance, but the police were greeted in peace. “Rua didn’t resist at all,” admitted one of the police officers years later.

The government expected conspiracy, but none was found. As for the weapons, they turned to be mostly ancient rifles incapable of being fired.

Prejudice and hysteria

Rua’s trial took 47 days, the longest in New Zealand legal history—a record it held until 1977. All the charges against Rua were dismissed, partly because, in his haste to apprehend the “desperado,” Cullen conducted his operation on a Sunday, in breach of the Lord’s Day Observance Act.

The jury rejected the charge of sedition and found Rua guilty only of offering “moral resistance” (as distinct from physical resistance) to constables who had sought to arrest him months earlier for the illicit sale of alcohol—a charge for which he believed he had already served time.

But that offence was enough for the judge to hand down a severe sentence of a year of hard labour followed by 18 months’ imprisonment.

“With his sentence,” wrote Judith Binney in her magisterial history of Tuhoe, Encircled Lands, “[Judge Frederick] Chapman befriended the prejudice and hysteria lurking in society”— traits that would surface again in the Urewera raids of 2007 and their aftermath.

As well as punishing Rua, Chapman levied the entire cost of the police operation on Rua and his community. It crippled them, and the community never recovered.

The one bright spot in Rua’s arrest, trial, imprisonment and financial punishment was the jury’s response to the verdict. They were dismayed. Eight jurors sent a petition to parliament objecting at the harsh sentence. Among the deep concerns they expressed was this: “we feel that the verdict as recorded is not our verdict and that in consequence Rua Kenana has been sentenced for a crime of which we did not find him guilty and will undergo a punishment when we feel is not according to our determination or to our consciences.”

“Our sympathies were and are entirely with Rua, both as to his treatment by the Magistrate and by the Police,” the eight jurors continued. “He was of the opinion that he was being persecuted and in that respect we shared his opinion.”

Such an action was unprecedented, but the jurors’ plea for a pardon or early release was ignored.

Moral light and social darkness

The moral light of these jurors could not penetrate the darkness of institutional racism. In a report commissioned to establish whether the Maungapohatu community needed assistance, Captain Herbert Macdonald wrote: “No anxiety need be felt as to Rua’s wives or children starving. Natives always help one another and if they ever become short of food they will either go back to their own people, or get married to other Natives.”

Judge J. W. Browne of the Waiariki Maori Land Court added, “The Tuhoe Natives are, if anything, more communistic than any other section of Natives in New Zealand . . . The offer of help too might possibly be misunderstood. It would probably be considered by most of the Natives as an indication of weakness on the part of the Government, and an acknowledgment that Rua had been badly used. The best way to assist them and to help European settlement at the same time will be to send the Land Purchase Officer into the district to continue the purchase of their surplus lands.”

The agenda, as always, was to prise open Te Urewera for Pakeha interests. With impeccable timing, on the very day that Rua was sentenced, William Massey’s Reform Government introduced legislation that validated its illegal purchasing of Urewera land.

Remembering Rua

When I was writing about Tuhoe for New Zealand Geographic in 2012, I visited Maungapohatu to meet some of Rua’s descendants and to acknowledge the history that was forged here. The wharenui still stands. I stood on the verandah where Rua faced Cullen. I stood in the river the police crossed as they prepared to apprehend the prophet. I walked through Rua’s derelict house, which should be a nationally respected historic place, but instead is full of old possum carcasses and is collapsing through neglect. I stood next to the cabbage trees in the urupa and climbed the lower slopes of the sacred mountain. And on a borrowed violin at sunset I played Fritz Kreisler’s tune “Liebesleid”—love’s sorrow—hoping to add the sweetness of that music to a place that has felt great bitterness and grief.

I cannot get out of my mind—and do not wish to—the words of Judith Binney, describing interviews with descendants of the people of Maungapohatu as she was writing the prophet’s history. She said that the photo of Rua’s arrest became crumpled and stained with tears from those she showed it to.

“Bitter as gall,” she wrote, are the memories of the people of the events of that day in 1916, Maungapohatu’s Bloody Sunday.

Tuhoe have been called the people of the mist. Mist and fog are a metaphor for forgetting, and Maungapohatu 1916, like Parihaka 1881—or Ruatoki 2007—must not be forgotten.

What George Orwell predicted must not happen: “Everything faded into mist. The past was erased, the erasure was forgotten, the lie became truth.”

One thought on “Tuhoe’s Bloody Sunday

  1. Thanks Kennedy.
    This is such an important story that needs to be told and retold to middle New Zealand.
    I really enjoyed your original 2012 artile in NZ Goegraphic.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>